I could care less about joining the club but I felt like answering the questions anyway. I haven't seen a ton of anime but a lot of what I have seen was great.
1)List your five favorite anime, and write why you like it.
1. Berserk : probably the best and most engaging story of all the animes I've watched. It is very epic, it provokes a lot of emotions, and it doesn't hold back in the violence, sex, or profanity departments.
2. Death Note: while I hear it didn't always follow the manga, this was a masterpiece. The first third of the series is probably one of the best television show experiences ever, regardless of whether it was live action, anime, or other. Because the rest of the show was not as good (although still amazing), Death Note falls right below Berserk.
3. Naruto: while many may disagree, I think Naruto is awesome. There is so much build up which pisses a lot of people off, but the climaxes are so great I explode in my pants every time, so I can forgive the slow/meaningless episodes. Great fight scenes, story, music, and the thing that stands out for me is that every character has a very distinct personality and fighting style, and there are so many of them.
I don't really have anything that comes close to the top 3, but here are other series that I loved that I have watched/am watching: Full metal alchemist, Code Geass, Gungrave (the first half), Hunter X Hunter (the first half), Claymore, Cowboy Bebop (overrated but entertaining), Samurai Champloo, Monster (just started watching it), Yu Yu Hakusho, and some other ones that I can't think of right now.
2)What got you into anime, and what kinds of anime do you like?
The first anime I watched (besides Dragonball Z, which every little kid watched back in the day) was Naruto. Some girl introduced me to it a couple years ago and I've enjoyed a bunch of animes since then. I prefer anime with a darker atmosphere like Death Note and Berserk but there are definitely many exceptions.
3)What kind of anime do you dislike
Bleach was horrible, One Piece was horrible, Dragonball GT was (obviously) horrible. I just hate anime that loses a sense of direction after a while, or that just sucks to begin with (like those cheesy pop animes with annoying characters, like Yu-Gi Oh and stuff). I don't watch sucky animes usually though, because I read up on them before hand. I'm picky I guess. Watching a few series here and there is too much of a time sink already, I can't waste more time watching crap.
I don't know why I wrote all this ...oh yeh cuz I'm a loser =(