I think, hands-down, the best conversation I've heard between a Priest and an Archeologist went like this:
Arch: "We believe we've found the human remains of Jesus. Based on the name on the tomb, and all of the other names on the tombs in the family vault, and the family mark on the front of the tomb, cross referenced with everything we know from historical documents about this family, there is a 1/640,000,000 chance this is NOT his remains.
Priest: "Why should I believe it is true then, since you cannot prove it? Since it is not 100%?"
Lulz.
Note- Even if the archeologist was wrong, the fact that someone would completely dismiss something with those odds is insane.