At 9/24/09 04:58 AM, Coop83 wrote:
And so long as they pass selection, surely. Spammy chat, like was the downfall of the NGPD would surely have the same results here.
Well, there's already a system in place to allow guardsmen into the Barracks, but yes, they do have to pass our quality standards, and yes, there will be zero tolerance for spammy chat.
At 9/23/09 10:00 PM, phantomlassuk wrote:
I wasn't shocked at all - warnings were issued, warnings were ignored. Punishment was levied, which may or may not be rescinded at a later date (I believe the latter).
I'm still thinking it might get unlocked, but yes, you are right that there were quite a few warnings over time. Of course, depending on your philosophy on moderation, the time period between stints of problems comes into play when making a decision as to whether or not the thread should be locked or not, which brings me to the next text to quote:
At 9/24/09 09:18 AM, SoulMaster71 wrote:
Interestingly enough, looking through those pages there were a few posts by Gooch, who originally thought this club was the problem, and one later admitting that it was the NGPD he didn't like. There were references to him being a mod at the time, certainly he bears the golden aura now, but has the NGPD really been on the mods' nerves that long?
Ah, you saw that, huh? Yeah, the NGPD has a long history like that, unfortunately.
The NGPD got started on the wrong foot right from the beginning, since it was Ramagi that felt it was nothing more than a copycat version of the Elite Guard Barracks. While they showed reason for it to stick around, it still caused problems for the moderators, as it set a precedent that many people tried to follow. I remember seeing what had to be at least 2 dozen "Safety Patroller Club" threads pop up over the following months, which was a constant thorn-in-the-side for the mods. Naturally, this wasn't what caused the problems with the NGPD, but it sure didn't help, as it was easy for them to second-guess whether the club caused more harm than good.
Once signs of mass-voting and one-liners came around, mods were quick to give warnings and threaten with closure. The Unit Ops at the time usually did a good job of quelling any issues and straightening out the thread (especially Peregrinus and Tails), but there were some really large blow-ups. One in particular that still resonates in my head is what happened with mutant-busterjr and his creating a club to maliciously attack spam groups. This created a whole big stink that got not only the NGPD and these spam groups involved, but it also attracted the attention of the mods.
All of these things are in the past, of course, but there were quite a few significant issues there. As of late, I would say that Tails has a good grasp on things and the troubles really aren't a worry, but the one-liner spamming seems to be persistent throughout the thread, at least until Tails lays down the law. While it's easy for someone to say Poozy went too far, there is certainly enough past there that warrants him doing what he did. One could argue that these events are ancient history (and some are), but even still, the problems were there. Either way, I'm sure the situation will resolve itself in one way or another, whether or not it involves the thread being unlocked.