this song was fully generated by a neural network. this also got Frontpaged. How could this be missed?
At 4/5/24 01:55 PM, G2961 wrote:https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1308160
this song was fully generated by a neural network. this also got Frontpaged. How could this be missed?
It also seems like many of the others songs are AI as well, they remind me of Suno.ai
At 4/5/24 06:17 PM, CielOuvert wrote:At 4/5/24 01:55 PM, G2961 wrote:https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1308160
this song was fully generated by a neural network. this also got Frontpaged. How could this be missed?
It also seems like many of the others songs are AI as well, they remind me of Suno.ai
yes. this is ai bad, beacuse background noise
At 4/5/24 06:40 PM, G2961 wrote:At 4/5/24 06:17 PM, CielOuvert wrote:At 4/5/24 01:55 PM, G2961 wrote:https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1308160
this song was fully generated by a neural network. this also got Frontpaged. How could this be missed?
It also seems like many of the others songs are AI as well, they remind me of Suno.ai
yes. this is ai bad, beacuse background noise
Another tell-tale sign is often an abrupt ending, since suno can't quite grasp outros
Hadn't noticed this before, but this track used in Portal submission 800,000 was actually stolen:
Original: 8 Bit Menu by David Renda:
https://music.apple.com/us/album/8-bit-menu/1529541716?i=1529542282
At 4/7/24 05:53 PM, BlamThisPlz wrote:6 Bad Audio Submissions!
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1311068
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1285305
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1284621
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1262843
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1262134
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1262162
Can't you just elaborate this more because what makes these submissions "bad" and how does that exactly violate the Audio Portal's guidelines? If it's something the lines of "oh it's terrible because [insert reasoning that doesn't involve said guidelines]" then you're wasting time here.
Came here from sister thread The Elite Guard Barracks because the author uploaded a low-effort Gwimbly flash and I'm suspicious.
This author's entire catalog were most likely recorded from people paid on Fiverr. IDK if this is completely allowed, but they are not credited on the NG upload, which goes against the Audio Guidelines:
Credit your vocalist!
If there are vocals in your song, please credit your vocalist. If you are using vocals from a pack or from on-line, it's helpful to note the source and confirm you have rights to use the vocals.
I know they only mention songs, but I thought it might also apply to spoken word narratives as well.
That being said, they are mostly credited on the YouTube versions, save for one:
Dictum Violare
VA: stephendaltonvoe on Fiverr
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ut6kSZLugAw
Campbell Family Shotgun
VA: rickmillervoice on Fiverr
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SZXFg_U9haU
Long Claws of Saturn:
YT version does not credit VA, could be author themselves, but given the other two, I can't be sure.
I'm pretty sure this was generated by an AI model, but I at least want a second opinion before reporting it. AI is getting scarily good. All the songs on this person's account sound similar and probably are generated by an AI model. They're all just a bit off. Even their profile picture looks somewhat AI generated. The user is Mrsawka.
Edit: Nevermind.
Stolen:
Original: Rock Your Life by Emmanuel David Lipszyc
Source: https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=zA2WmZ0WB_s&list=PLtmZcsapP2iCVksWwp7XSonBe7wpllPFd
Professional media sourcerer looking for your requests
Purple & Red (newgrounds.com) (IT WAS FRONTPAGED!!!)
I Knew You Would (newgrounds.com)
this VERY seems to Suno AI generation. Also his prevous songs VEEEERY seems to Suno AI generation.
Maybe this is noise from Suno AI for copyrighting.
Also quality is so-so
ARTIX - Breakfast (newgrounds.com)
STOP USE SUNO AI!!
Explanation why I called this song Suno generated, songs generated with Suno have such a low bitrate and such noise in some places. You can see for yourself by trying this neural network.
It's very frustrating when you work hard on new songs and you don't get much, and then some neural network that made you a song in 1 minute and you illegally uploaded it to the audio portal, and it gets on the main page. Do something about it.
He also has another song that got frontpaged. it's horrible.
why really no one does anything about this? who puts this on the frontpage? why does no one hear this noise that proves this is a Suno generated song?
At 4/19/24 07:18 PM, G2961 wrote:ARTIX - Breakfast (newgrounds.com)
STOP USE SUNO AI!!
Explanation why I called this song Suno generated, songs generated with Suno have such a low bitrate and such noise in some places. You can see for yourself by trying this neural network.
I wasn't aware that Suno would do songs up to 3 minutes or such clarity in the instrumentation. Can you send me a PM what points of this song are glaringly AI? To me it just sounds like someone went too hard on Sausage Fattener on certain parts of the instrumental.
PSA: @Porter has had a car accident and needs your help! See news!
Music producer freebies here -- ALL my big sample projects are FREE!
audio critique & commissions. Catch me on YT!
At 4/19/24 07:22 PM, ADR3-N wrote:At 4/19/24 07:18 PM, G2961 wrote:ARTIX - Breakfast (newgrounds.com)
STOP USE SUNO AI!!
Explanation why I called this song Suno generated, songs generated with Suno have such a low bitrate and such noise in some places. You can see for yourself by trying this neural network.
I wasn't aware that Suno would do songs up to 3 minutes or such clarity in the instrumentation.
You can continue the song and make longer tracks, the continuation is often recognizable on the wave pattern as an abrupt stop or bridge.
We live in a world where songs generated by Suno AI end up on the main page of a creative website and do nothing about it. These are the songs generated by Suno AI. This background noise and low bitrate gives out this neural network, and moderators allow some of these songs to the main page. That is, while real musicians work hard on songs and mostly get little, then some neural network picked up a user under the nickname "Fate". All his songs for the end of 2023 and the beginning of 2024 were completely generated by Suno AI.
The user says in this description that it is not theirs, but I don't know the source and don't feel like sifting through hours of ASMR ear licking to find the original. If someone finds the source, please report it.
Less than 1 second long beep:
Uploader's profile might require an additional attention. The news post with the rating E links a Youtube video which is likely to be banned there, because it has an explicit scene in it.
Professional media sourcerer looking for your requests
At 4/23/24 09:01 PM, G2961 wrote:We live in a world where songs generated by Suno AI end up on the main page of a creative website and do nothing about it. These are the songs generated by Suno AI. This background noise and low bitrate gives out this neural network, and moderators allow some of these songs to the main page. That is, while real musicians work hard on songs and mostly get little, then some neural network picked up a user under the nickname "Fate". All his songs for the end of 2023 and the beginning of 2024 were completely generated by Suno AI.
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1316287
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1316239
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1314771
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1313736
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1313008
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1299503
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1304721
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1299110
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1296636
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1296151
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1277120
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1273418
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1273371
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1272521
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1271776
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1271012
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1268475
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1268173
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1267994
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1267742
You were 100% on point. I listened to all of these and they appear to have been generated with AI, low bit rate, artefacting, inconsistent instrument attacks and decays. As someone who uses AI models myself, it was very evident.
Y'all, keep an eye out for these. AI is getting close to human output. I'm sure we're going to have a LOT of impostors soon.
PSA: @Porter has had a car accident and needs your help! See news!
Music producer freebies here -- ALL my big sample projects are FREE!
audio critique & commissions. Catch me on YT!
At 4/19/24 07:22 PM, ADR3-N wrote:At 4/19/24 07:18 PM, G2961 wrote:ARTIX - Breakfast (newgrounds.com)
STOP USE SUNO AI!!
Explanation why I called this song Suno generated, songs generated with Suno have such a low bitrate and such noise in some places. You can see for yourself by trying this neural network.
I wasn't aware that Suno would do songs up to 3 minutes or such clarity in the instrumentation. Can you send me a PM what points of this song are glaringly AI? To me it just sounds like someone went too hard on Sausage Fattener on certain parts of the instrumental.
Can you also check out user @Mrsawka? Their songs appear to be generated with Sumo AI as well. They say that they "made the pattern", but I have no idea what that means and I doubt they had any part in the creation of their posed music other than a prompt. Can you maybe investigate more? The one song where they commented and admitted to using AI was deleted, but I have a screenshot of what they said, and it still might be visible to a mod anyway.
These songs are still up:
Just thought I should bring this up again with AI at the forefront of the conversation.
Can you also check out user @Mrsawka?
I seem to know him, he makes video cuts from the streams of such a Geometry Dash youtuber, whose nickname is DeCody
At 4/23/24 10:00 PM, Questtrek wrote:Can you also check out user @Mrsawka?
Investigated and you were correct. Whole catalog was AI generated.
I'm not surprised this is happening. GD players think they've cracked the code on getting around content ID: I won't learn to make my own music like the mods have been telling everyone to do for ages. I'll use this app to generate cookie cutter crap instead. Then I'll definitely get scouted and get the approval of the elder mods on GD discord, and people will think I'm good at music despite every genre swap changing the mystery vocalist I don't name.
I'm sure there will be more where this came from, and I smell free whistle points, so if you have friends in the AP, tag them to follow this thread and keep those reports coming. The more users who know about AI music and are looking for it, the easier it can be rooted out of the portal.
PSA: @Porter has had a car accident and needs your help! See news!
Music producer freebies here -- ALL my big sample projects are FREE!
audio critique & commissions. Catch me on YT!
At 4/23/24 11:54 PM, ADR3-N wrote:At 4/23/24 10:00 PM, Questtrek wrote:Can you also check out user @Mrsawka?
Investigated and you were correct. Whole catalog was AI generated.
I'm not surprised this is happening. GD players think they've cracked the code on getting around content ID: I won't learn to make my own music like the mods have been telling everyone to do for ages. I'll use this app to generate cookie cutter crap instead. Then I'll definitely get scouted and get the approval of the elder mods on GD discord, and people will think I'm good at music despite every genre swap changing the mystery vocalist I don't name.
I'm sure there will be more where this came from, and I smell free whistle points, so if you have friends in the AP, tag them to follow this thread and keep those reports coming. The more users who know about AI music and are looking for it, the easier it can be rooted out of the portal.
Thank you for taking a look at that, and yeah, I'll definitely post my other findings of AI-generated "music" on this thread. It's only going to get more rampant from here. I feel like there should be better systems (and education) in place for detecting AI-generated songs though, as Fate should have never gotten frontpaged, let alone gotten frontpaged multiple times. People just need to be better versed in what AI music is and what it sounds like. I almost feel there should be a sitewide PSA talking about how to spot AI generated content (not just music, but images too). I'm well versed in AI too, and it pains me to see it slowly invade Newgrounds. Anyway, that's just my two cents, thanks again for taking down those songs.
Two more AI-generated songs I found today. Both said they used Suno AI in the description.
At 4/24/24 12:26 AM, Questtrek wrote:Thank you for taking a look at that, and yeah, I'll definitely post my other findings of AI-generated "music" on this thread. It's only going to get more rampant from here. I feel like there should be better systems (and education) in place for detecting AI-generated songs though, as Fate should have never gotten frontpaged, let alone gotten frontpaged multiple times. People just need to be better versed in what AI music is and what it sounds like. I almost feel there should be a sitewide PSA talking about how to spot AI generated content (not just music, but images too). I'm well versed in AI too, and it pains me to see it slowly invade Newgrounds. Anyway, that's just my two cents, thanks again for taking down those songs.
AI "music" is such a new thing, I don't expect the general public or even all the moderators on here to be aware of just how good it has gotten (at flying under the radar). You remember the old AI videos of Will Smith eating spaghetti with horribly disfigured facial expressions and like 3 hands at the same time, sometimes being eaten by the spaghetti? Yeah. That's not happening anymore. AI music used to be basically the same time, or limited to midi. Now, it's ... this.
I don't expect the musicians in the portal to know much about it either. If they're good noodles, music generators are probably the furthest thing from their mind. It's the tool of scammers and spammers. And GD thieves.
Until we get AI to detect AI generated music, this will continue. For now AI music can't be copyrighted since it isn't created by a human, and we owe it to ourselves to have it taken down wherever we can. We can prob pre-empt it by keeping an eye on what bitrates the AIs are throwing out, but this is not fool proof as I saw one person in the portal who has been submitting 128 kbps music since 2019, and I don't THINK AI gen was that good in 2019. I can't remember hearing much about it then at all actually.
Keep the reports coming!
PSA: @Porter has had a car accident and needs your help! See news!
Music producer freebies here -- ALL my big sample projects are FREE!
audio critique & commissions. Catch me on YT!
Daily dose of AI generated garbage!
The first one sounds pretty damn good (minus the vocals).
At 4/24/24 07:36 PM, Questtrek wrote:Daily dose of AI generated garbage!
The first one sounds pretty damn good (minus the vocals).
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1316867
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1306752
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1303149
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1303468
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1315562
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1282947
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1283348
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1262565
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1262538
Another batch of removals ;)
Thank you!
PSA: @Porter has had a car accident and needs your help! See news!
Music producer freebies here -- ALL my big sample projects are FREE!
audio critique & commissions. Catch me on YT!
Day 3 of AI generated garbage!
AI Songs:
Accounts of shame:
https://coralzone2.newgrounds.com
https://oblexisoficial.newgrounds.com
Stollen, just Electroman with some meme sounds, both still have the tik tok sound at the end. If not stollen, still not allowed. It's a mashup, not a remix.
I think this is a recording of another song, but I can’t tell what it is.
This might be AI too, but I’m unsure.
A couple more AI sons I found:
(investigate this account too)
This account might be posting AI songs too:
Day 4 of AI generated garbage:
Found this account uploading Suno AI songs, trying to get scouted for GD purposes. This one had no shame.
Another GD user uploading AI songs. A lot more this time.
Every song had a bitrate of 192kbps, usually seen with Suno generations.
Accounts of shame:
Fucking reupload of KOHCTAHTA by AXIUS LINK. He even has a scout.
