00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme
Upgrade Your Account!

HO HO HOPE you become a Newgrounds Supporter this year!

We're working hard to give you the best site possible, but we have bills to pay and community support is vital to keep things going and growing. Thank you for considering!

Become a Supporter so NG can see another Christmas!

Official "Review for Review" Thread

436,585 Views | 4,240 Replies
New Topic Respond to this Topic

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-07 20:22:28


OKAY LET'S TRY THIS AGAIN

So I reviewed this:

V A M P I R E(as Trancera)

I would like some feedback on this:

Tense Like Glass

Thanks!


Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-09 18:29:16


At 4/9/15 06:17 PM, tmonster2002 wrote: Reviewed this: http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/617161

Peeps, look at this, I need it scouted. http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/618368

Do not, I repeat, do not scout this person. I, and many others here, will not support stolen content. You don't own it, you don't get the right to post it anywhere you want to - unless given explicit permission to do so.

Reported.

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-09 18:31:28


I own a copy of the game it is from.


At 4/9/15 06:31 PM, tmonster2002 wrote: I own a copy of the game it is from.

we aren't allowing one line reviews here. this isn't soundcloud.

also, congrats you're gonna get banned from posting audio that YOU DIDN'T MAKE YOURSELF


lel

BBS Signature

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-09 18:36:31


At 4/9/15 06:33 PM, Sequenced wrote:
At 4/9/15 06:31 PM, tmonster2002 wrote: I own a copy of the game it is from.
we aren't allowing one line reviews here. this isn't soundcloud.

also, congrats you're gonna get banned from posting audio that YOU DIDN'T MAKE YOURSELF

Ok, I'm sorry....
I'll delete it... I just wanted to make a Geometry Dash level...

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-10 15:52:57



A strong emphasis on underlining.

CLICK ME >>>>

BBS Signature

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-10 18:01:21


At 4/10/15 03:52 PM, Gergaloth wrote: I reviewed this little badass
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/617579
Please review
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/618709
thank you

Yo homes, you gotta review the song most recently posted, no a random one. I made the same mistake like two days ago.

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-10 20:15:07


At 4/10/15 06:01 PM, IndustryStandard wrote:
At 4/10/15 03:52 PM, Gergaloth wrote: I reviewed this little badass
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/617579
Please review
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/618709
thank you
Yo homes, you gotta review the song most recently posted, no a random one. I made the same mistake like two days ago.

Reviewed

Please review


A strong emphasis on underlining.

CLICK ME >>>>

BBS Signature

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-12 20:32:07


Reviewed the above

Would like this reviewed

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-13 12:39:01



Frozenth, you should probably focus on just reviewing the one song that is next on the list. You reviewed like 5 tracks with split effort put into all of them which left my track hanging hard.

I mean it's nice that you leave things on other songs, but at least give the latest song (e.g. mine) a more constructive review. If everyone else left those type of reviews on the latest track, the thread would be nearly worthless.

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-14 02:17:35


At 4/13/15 07:24 PM, Lethal-Input wrote: Frozenth, you should probably focus on just reviewing the one song that is next on the list. You reviewed like 5 tracks with split effort put into all of them which left my track hanging hard.

I mean it's nice that you leave things on other songs, but at least give the latest song (e.g. mine) a more constructive review. If everyone else left those type of reviews on the latest track, the thread would be nearly worthless.

Ok. I reviewed

as well.

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-14 02:42:58


This thread needs a mercy killing. Seriously, what happened.


BBS Signature

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-14 02:59:35


At 4/14/15 02:17 AM, Kelpalots wrote:
Ok. I reviewed
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/619175
as well.

one line reviews aren't allowed here get the fuck out of here dude


lel

BBS Signature

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-14 08:49:14


At 4/14/15 02:59 AM, Sequenced wrote:
At 4/14/15 02:17 AM, Kelpalots wrote:
Ok. I reviewed
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/619175
as well.
one line reviews aren't allowed here get the fuck out of here dude

Quit biting the people who make this community what it is. If you want to give advice, give advice, but don't go barking up my tree, or anyone else's.

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-14 11:06:21


At 4/14/15 02:59 AM, Sequenced wrote:
At 4/14/15 02:17 AM, Kelpalots wrote:
Ok. I reviewed
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/619175
as well.
one line reviews aren't allowed here get the fuck out of here dude

Also, I didn't want to give away the storyline. Then we can talk about long reviews then. If I spoil it for everyone, whose the fool then?


You should try reading the OP. The topic is for leaving thought out, constructive feedback on the LAST track on the waitlist. By that, I mean the latest track that has be asked to be reviewed in the thread. That review you posted had absolutely nothing constructive.

Now tell, me, if we all went out to review any track we wanted instead of the latest one, would this thread make any sense? We'd post a track and it wouldn't even be guaranteed a review because everyone would go and review the tracks they please.

Kelpalots wrote
"Also, I didn't want to give away the storyline. Then we can talk about long reviews then. If I spoil it for everyone, whose the fool then?"

Kelpalots's review on "A Normal Day" "Interesting story. Very well put together. It almost seems like a movie instead of a track!"

Ok I'll admit, I lol'd


At 4/14/15 11:54 AM, Lethal-Input wrote: You should try reading the OP. The topic is for leaving thought out, constructive feedback on the LAST track on the waitlist. By that, I mean the latest track that has be asked to be reviewed in the thread. That review you posted had absolutely nothing constructive.

Now tell, me, if we all went out to review any track we wanted instead of the latest one, would this thread make any sense? We'd post a track and it wouldn't even be guaranteed a review because everyone would go and review the tracks they please.

Kelpalots wrote
"Also, I didn't want to give away the storyline. Then we can talk about long reviews then. If I spoil it for everyone, whose the fool then?"

Kelpalots's review on "A Normal Day" "Interesting story. Very well put together. It almost seems like a movie instead of a track!"

Ok I'll admit, I lol'd

Ok thanks for your input. I was confused myself [what if I don't get reviews because of this setup], as I saw multiple people do the same thing, and I usually use that as context if I want to get to know a thread. But you're right, I should have read the topic description to begin with.

Also, tooth aches and seizures make you say lulzy things. lol I'm sure sometime within the next few months, I'll have honed in on better review skills. I'd like to challenge myself sometimes without trying to get into the music. :)

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-15 05:03:18


I reviewed

Please review

I'm constantly afraid I'm still not doing this correctly, but I haven't been chastised in a while so here you go


A strong emphasis on underlining.

CLICK ME >>>>

BBS Signature

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-16 18:06:15


I reviewed:

Want reviewed:

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-17 00:55:15


Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-17 10:54:24


Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2015-04-17 11:18:25


I don't want to be a bitch, but it highly despleases me when someone just posts a "review" to get a review themselves. A one liner is not a review.

"Really enjoyed this. Very lucid..."

I will request a proper review now, thanks: