00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme
Upgrade Your Account!

HO HO HOPE you become a Newgrounds Supporter this year!

We're working hard to give you the best site possible, but we have bills to pay and community support is vital to keep things going and growing. Thank you for considering!

Become a Supporter so NG can see another Christmas!

Review Request Club

834,030 Views | 8,821 Replies
New Topic Respond to this Topic

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-10 16:35:19


Hey guys, I already got all of the art reviews and I am heading for all requests done this week so I might be at 100% this week! Now time to review the flash which should take a while


Need a Review? Go to Review Request Club

Also please look at my art!

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-10 20:31:13


Making a request for some of my ART well all my art, i am hoping there is some new blood in here since last time i did a request on my art was some time ago

#1
http://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/xwayn ecoltx/chckerboard-1

#2
http://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/xwayn ecoltx/chess-checketboard-2

#3
http://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/xwayn ecoltx/palm-tree

#4
http://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/xwayn ecoltx/checkerboard-3

I really like art and stuff so it would be a pleasure to get some reviews and for my art to be more noticed, so thanks in advance, and i do promise to respond to these, if i have not responded to them i will get on top of that very shortly

~X~


~X~ (FOLLOW-ME)

[] The Top Reviewer Since 2002 [] COMIC >> WAYNES WORLD

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-10 21:09:27


This is a new DnB work-in-progress I have made. I have been wanting to get a better idea of where to go from what I have now, mainly for two reasons. First, it is now too big to play on my computer without rendering it, so it will take forever to mix and master and second, because I am pretty unexperienced and have been listening to it so much that I'm sure I'm somewhat biased at this point. i just would like some feedback. As always, I will greatly appreciate any reviews and will reply to every single one (not alot anyways).

Thanks guys.

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-10 23:51:30


Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-11 04:25:02


It has come to my attention, that I've reviewed a submission that's in the list before I was in the club (in the noob days xD). Do I just skip that one? I'm not going to add it to my points, but just if there's a way of maybe editing my review?


Watch how I contribute NOTHING to EVERY thread I post in!

My downloadable music | My art.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-11 08:40:01


Hi NG, love this site and thanks to all who make it possible. I'm with hope that this is the proper place to ask for a review of our latest project? If not, would someone be kind enough to direct us to the proper forum? Thanks in advance and here's our request for review:

We just finished SpeedE The WFD and submitted it here at http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/52 9984

We would love to get your honest thoughts and construtive input to SpeedE The WFD.

Again thanks to all and we look forward to being a part of the NG community.........:)

M-E

Review Request Club

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-11 09:25:31


At 3/11/10 04:25 AM, ChampionAnwar wrote: It has come to my attention, that I've reviewed a submission that's in the list before I was in the club (in the noob days xD). Do I just skip that one? I'm not going to add it to my points, but just if there's a way of maybe editing my review?

Just don't worry about it. It'll add right to your points and you'll just miss the points that you didn't get if you didn't put the RRC signature on it. I've reviewed many submissions from the past and it's always happened this way. If you are worried about points then you should sign all of your reviews RRC, but if not then there aren't any worries.

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-11 13:34:57


Hi. Does somebody please want to review 3 of my art pieces? Here they are:

The Colour Of Water
Siamese Octopuss Creature Killer Teddy


My Deviantart | NG Art | Youtube Channel | Art Portfolio

Shameless self-promotion ftw!

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-11 14:40:30


ouch. sorry for not getting any reviews done last week, I had a really busy week. should be a lot better this week.

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-11 17:23:56


Thanks for reviewing my stuff guys! Made my day, to leave a comment on my very heart warming reviews!


BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-11 21:36:04


This is the reason for why I'm still in this club, you keep discovering more and more GREAT musics every week, that's so gratifying...

;)


Hey you, looking for fun? Join the Elite Guard Barracks

Signature by CagedSilhouette!!

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-12 03:17:36


Out of My Sight

I haven't posted for a request in quite a while, and haven't really worked on music. Reviews would be highly appreciated. Anything you can hear wrong or that could be better, I need criticism!

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-12 09:44:11


Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-12 15:28:09



Bipolar Smiley: (:(

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-12 15:29:02


At 3/9/10 02:30 PM, Supersteph54 wrote: Wow, this is a superb week for the RRC. I mean, weeks like this really make me feel proud that I have the honour to actually update for such an awesome club. If next week's going to be like this week, or even half as good as this week, it'd be awesome.

The only reason I'm reviewing all of this weeks submissions is because it makes you proud. After this it'll probably just be back to the art and or flash reviews. I might even take a break once I get to 1,000 flash and 1,000 audio reviews. It's really taken a lot of time out of my day.

6 people, yes, 6, managed all of the requests. Fro even did all of the requests, which might mean he'll do it again next time and the club'll be back to its usual glory of with the Top 3 growing stronger in stats as the weeks pass.

I think this week will be my last if I even finish it up. I'm trying though.

Great to see 4 new members: Animith, borntodj167, ChampionAnwar and Lublub194, and great to see that all of them, Animith in particular, are writing such fantastic reviews.

Ah yes, this gives me even more reason to semi-retire from reviewing! With so many great members coming in then there really isn't much need for me to continue against my will.

Now if only I manage to convince Darklight to come back and do his 100% ratios again, then we'd have 7 100% ratio members, and you all know that 7 is an awesome number xD.

I do miss his reviews on my submissions. :P

Only 2 people, TheSongSalad and SCTE3, didn't manage any requests (excluding me, but I had HTML to do :[ ). Joshsouza did a decent amount, and so did ChampionAnwar and Lublub, plus Celx-Requin managed a few reviews too. Sorry for not reviewing at all this week, I was really busy. In other news, Coop83 and Haggard also made it to a whopping 5000 points, and I'm getting closer to 2000 points.

It's hard to believe that I would have been right up there behind Haggard if I would have gotten 100% every time. Looks like my third place is holding up strong for the moment being though so it's something to be proud of.

By the way, Lublub isn't exactly a full member, but he made quite a few reviews, and quite a few were very well written, so I thought we could make one exception and let him through even though he didn't post the points he gained since it was his first week. Sorry if I did the wrong thing :(.

That's up to you. You're the one that keeps the club running my friend.


Anyway, all in all a great week. The only 2 downfalls are that mrty and Little-Rena have to be excluded from the list and that RogerBK did not fulfill his dream yet and pass someone in points xP. But maybe next time xD. Took me pretty long to make this update with all the new members and a large amount of requests, but here it is. Enjoy!

Yet another reason for me to leave! It'll be one less member for you to have to worry about when updating your lists.

Member's Update #35
[#] [Total] [Total Stats] [Total Ratio] || [Gain] [Weekly Stats] [Weekly Ratio] [Username]
1 ) 5073 | 790 / 790 | 100.00% || 166 | 26 / 26 | 100.00% | Coop83
2 ) 5048 | 786 / 791 | 099.37% || 166 | 26 / 26 | 100.00% | Haggard
3 ) 2723 | 420 / 770 | 054.55% || 166 | 26 / 26 | 100.00% | Fro

The three amigos strike again. The portals need to be careful when us three get loose.

*New To the List: Animith, borntodj167, ChampionAnwar and Lublub194

Welcome everyone.

Leaving the List: mrty and Little-Rena

Little-Rena yet again!


*All Requests Completed:
Coop83, Haggard, Fro, borntodj167, Animith and RogerBK

Nice to see some new names and some old names on here again. Nice to see my name on here again.

At 3/9/10 03:10 PM, Animith wrote:
Hoping this is okay

Hey thanks a lot for updating this so quickly. The few mistakes you made weren't really noticeable at all. Good job.

At 3/10/10 02:46 PM, Haggard wrote:
Yeah, three amigos strike again! About time! :)

I had somethings to take care of, but I'm back to join my brothers.

At 3/10/10 03:06 PM, Supersteph54 wrote:
At 3/10/10 02:46 PM, Haggard wrote:
*All Requests Completed:
Coop83, Haggard, Fro, borntodj167, Animith and RogerBK
Ah, quite crowded in here. We need new supply of beer!
Shh, some people in there are underage xD.

Hm, I know for a fact that the three amigos aren't underage. Perhaps the others can watch. Remember, I'm built like a tank so perhaps that's why we need the new supply of beer. ;)

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-12 16:33:19


At 3/9/10 02:30 PM, Supersteph54 wrote: In other news, Coop83 and Haggard also made it to a whopping 5000 points, and I'm getting closer to 2000 points. One time I'll try and get all of the requests in one week, and then I'll get myself to 2000.

Thanks for the ego boost there - I've been puttering along slowly this time, but today was my Uncle's funeral and it's been quite emotional these past few weeks. Tomorrow might be better, but we'll have to see, as the emotions have spilled over today, as I'm sure you can imagine.

[#] [Total] [Total Stats] [Total Ratio] || [Gain] [Weekly Stats] [Weekly Ratio] [Username]
1 ) 5073 | 790 / 790 | 100.00% || 166 | 26 / 26 | 100.00% | Coop83
2 ) 5048 | 786 / 791 | 099.37% || 166 | 26 / 26 | 100.00% | Haggard
3 ) 2723 | 420 / 770 | 054.55% || 166 | 26 / 26 | 100.00% | Fro

Well, I've got to add Fro back to this little list. Perhaps I'll be able to stick it at the top for another week, but with another massive load of Audio requests, I'm not holding out much hope at this stage.

*All Requests Completed:
Coop83, Haggard, Fro, borntodj167, Animith and RogerBK

Congratulations, your people have helped myself and Haggard feel less lonely :P


Will it ever end. Yes, all human endeavour is pointless ~ Bill Bailey

News

#StoryShift Author

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-12 16:37:09


At 3/12/10 03:29 PM, Fro wrote:
At 3/9/10 02:30 PM, Supersteph54 wrote: Wow, this is a superb week for the RRC. I mean, weeks like this really make me feel proud that I have the honour to actually update for such an awesome club. If next week's going to be like this week, or even half as good as this week, it'd be awesome.
The only reason I'm reviewing all of this weeks submissions is because it makes you proud. After this it'll probably just be back to the art and or flash reviews. I might even take a break once I get to 1,000 flash and 1,000 audio reviews. It's really taken a lot of time out of my day.

Hey, I'm sure it made all of the members proud to be part of this club, not just me ^^.

6 people, yes, 6, managed all of the requests. Fro even did all of the requests, which might mean he'll do it again next time and the club'll be back to its usual glory of with the Top 3 growing stronger in stats as the weeks pass.
I think this week will be my last if I even finish it up. I'm trying though.

:(

Great to see 4 new members: Animith, borntodj167, ChampionAnwar and Lublub194, and great to see that all of them, Animith in particular, are writing such fantastic reviews.
Ah yes, this gives me even more reason to semi-retire from reviewing! With so many great members coming in then there really isn't much need for me to continue against my will.

But the point is you're probably one of the best reviewers on the club. Your flash and art reviews smash mine into thousands of pieces (or characters in this case xD) and although my music reviews are longer than yours, heck, my music reviews are longer than quite a few people's reviews anyway xP. So yeah, it's hard to find a replacement ^^.

Now if only I manage to convince Darklight to come back and do his 100% ratios again, then we'd have 7 100% ratio members, and you all know that 7 is an awesome number xD.
I do miss his reviews on my submissions. :P

I miss going to school and telling him stuff like "You finished the reviews? Huh? Huh? No? You're going to lose your 100% ratio!", and that nagging is probably what kept him going for so long :P. Then, the one time he didn't manage to finish all of them, he quit xP.

Only 2 people, TheSongSalad and SCTE3, didn't manage any requests (excluding me, but I had HTML to do :[ ). Joshsouza did a decent amount, and so did ChampionAnwar and Lublub, plus Celx-Requin managed a few reviews too. Sorry for not reviewing at all this week, I was really busy. In other news, Coop83 and Haggard also made it to a whopping 5000 points, and I'm getting closer to 2000 points.
It's hard to believe that I would have been right up there behind Haggard if I would have gotten 100% every time. Looks like my third place is holding up strong for the moment being though so it's something to be proud of.

Yeah, and I'm probably going to stick to fourth for quite a long time unless you're inactive for four weeks. However, if I see anyone catching up, I will retaliate >:3.

By the way, Lublub isn't exactly a full member, but he made quite a few reviews, and quite a few were very well written, so I thought we could make one exception and let him through even though he didn't post the points he gained since it was his first week. Sorry if I did the wrong thing :(.
That's up to you. You're the one that keeps the club running my friend.

But if it wasn't for you regs, I wouldn't even be in this club anyway :/.

Anyway, all in all a great week. The only 2 downfalls are that mrty and Little-Rena have to be excluded from the list and that RogerBK did not fulfill his dream yet and pass someone in points xP. But maybe next time xD. Took me pretty long to make this update with all the new members and a large amount of requests, but here it is. Enjoy!
Yet another reason for me to leave! It'll be one less member for you to have to worry about when updating your lists.

I'd prefer you stay and I still have one more member to worry about, but whatever :P.

Shh, some people in there are underage xD.
Hm, I know for a fact that the three amigos aren't underage. Perhaps the others can watch. Remember, I'm built like a tank so perhaps that's why we need the new supply of beer. ;)

Modesty shines in those words :P.


Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-12 18:41:43


Ahhhhhh...

It's finally Friday, I'll try to finish those reviews, because tomorrow I don't have class, so, I'm going to be on my Netbook (I love him, his name is Dagofrederico... :3) until 1 or 2 a.m.

YEAHHH!!!


Hey you, looking for fun? Join the Elite Guard Barracks

Signature by CagedSilhouette!!

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-12 23:20:02


Ahh, I've started kinda late this week. But I have an entire weekend of nothing else to do, so hopefully I'll manage to smash through them all by Sunday....maybe. Starting on the art ones now, anyway ;D

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-12 23:58:28


At 3/12/10 11:20 PM, Animith wrote: Ahh, I've started kinda late this week. But I have an entire weekend of nothing else to do, so hopefully I'll manage to smash through them all by Sunday....maybe. Starting on the art ones now, anyway ;D

This will be some hard work Animith, you lazy girl...

We'll see if everyone make every request, like last week... I'll be so Proud, just like SuperSteph...

:3 *PROUD*


Hey you, looking for fun? Join the Elite Guard Barracks

Signature by CagedSilhouette!!

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-13 03:41:20


well I got all the flash and audio reviews done and I think I will be able to finish all of the audio reviews by Monday or earlier since I am staying up late tonight because of a friday


Need a Review? Go to Review Request Club

Also please look at my art!

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-13 04:40:04


The week's looking good so far :D.


Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-13 06:54:12


At 3/12/10 11:58 PM, RogerBK wrote:
At 3/12/10 11:20 PM, Animith wrote: Ahh, I've started kinda late this week. But I have an entire weekend of nothing else to do, so hopefully I'll manage to smash through them all by Sunday....maybe. Starting on the art ones now, anyway ;D
This will be some hard work Animith, you lazy girl...

We'll see if everyone make every request, like last week... I'll be so Proud, just like SuperSteph...

3 *PROUD*

What can I say...I like a challenge ;D
I'll get them done. Would have started earlier, but life got in the way of my interwebs this week more than I'd've liked. xD
Still got two days, though. Plenty o' time.

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-13 08:32:03


Posting in this thread again made me remember why I enjoyed the club so much before... getting 100% was more than just reviewing all of the requests...

At 3/11/10 09:36 PM, RogerBK wrote: This is the reason for why I'm still in this club, you keep discovering more and more GREAT musics every week, that's so gratifying...

;)

I also agree. That was a very good piece! It went right to my favorite song of all time on newgrounds. :)

At 3/12/10 04:37 PM, Supersteph54 wrote:
But the point is you're probably one of the best reviewers on the club. Your flash and art reviews smash mine into thousands of pieces (or characters in this case xD) and although my music reviews are longer than yours, heck, my music reviews are longer than quite a few people's reviews anyway xP. So yeah, it's hard to find a replacement ^^.

I wouldn't say I'm one of the best reviewers of the club. You have this attitude that quality = quantity and that's not what I feel at all. Even though I understand they are almost always positively correlated, it's doesn't really mean causation. I feel that because I don't know much about audio and audio is almost all that we get here then I can't really make quality reviews. Especially after listening to so many in a row and after awhile they all sound exactly like songs that I've heard before... It does grow tiresome. I wish there were less audio in this club.

I miss going to school and telling him stuff like "You finished the reviews? Huh? Huh? No? You're going to lose your 100% ratio!", and that nagging is probably what kept him going for so long :P. Then, the one time he didn't manage to finish all of them, he quit xP.

Talk him back into joining. There's nothing wrong with some positive peer pressure every now and then. Perhaps if he doesn't want to rejoin I should just send a PM his way and have him review some of my stuff that he missed.

Yeah, and I'm probably going to stick to fourth for quite a long time unless you're inactive for four weeks. However, if I see anyone catching up, I will retaliate >:3.

Can't I be granted some sort of immunity where I don't ever get kicked off the list? :(

But if it wasn't for you regs, I wouldn't even be in this club anyway :/.

If it wasn't for us regs there would always be other regs probably. *Head gets bigger* But I guess it is hard to find people like us around this website. *Yawns and flexes*

Modesty shines in those words :P.

Modesty is one of my best traits, but I can go on and on about my other great traits. ;)

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-13 09:09:16


At 3/13/10 08:32 AM, Fro wrote: Posting in this thread again made me remember why I enjoyed the club so much before... getting 100% was more than just reviewing all of the requests...

Yeah, I miss quoting Sonofkirk's updates xD.

At 3/11/10 09:36 PM, RogerBK wrote: This is the reason for why I'm still in this club, you keep discovering more and more GREAT musics every week, that's so gratifying...

;)
I also agree. That was a very good piece! It went right to my favorite song of all time on newgrounds. :)

I found some really awesome tunes requested too ^^.

At 3/12/10 04:37 PM, Supersteph54 wrote:
But the point is you're probably one of the best reviewers on the club. Your flash and art reviews smash mine into thousands of pieces (or characters in this case xD) and although my music reviews are longer than yours, heck, my music reviews are longer than quite a few people's reviews anyway xP. So yeah, it's hard to find a replacement ^^.
I wouldn't say I'm one of the best reviewers of the club. You have this attitude that quality = quantity and that's not what I feel at all.

Obviously quantity does not mean quality. My atitude is more Quality AND Quantity > Quality xD, and I suppose that's what your flash and art reviews are. Quality and Quantity. Anyway, enough philosphy dammit.

Even though I understand they are almost always positively correlated, it's doesn't really mean causation. I feel that because I don't know much about audio and audio is almost all that we get here then I can't really make quality reviews. Especially after listening to so many in a row and after awhile they all sound exactly like songs that I've heard before... It does grow tiresome.

That doesn't make you not the best reviewer in the club. It just gives you less opportunities to show your true potential, but you're still probably the best reviewer in the club, at least in my opinion.

I wish there were less audio in this club.

Don't we all ^^.

I miss going to school and telling him stuff like "You finished the reviews? Huh? Huh? No? You're going to lose your 100% ratio!", and that nagging is probably what kept him going for so long :P. Then, the one time he didn't manage to finish all of them, he quit xP.
Talk him back into joining. There's nothing wrong with some positive peer pressure every now and then. Perhaps if he doesn't want to rejoin I should just send a PM his way and have him review some of my stuff that he missed.

Yeah, and it's fun nagging him anyway :P. He said he might join, but he'll think about it. If he doesn't, flood him with some of your flash submissions >:3.

Yeah, and I'm probably going to stick to fourth for quite a long time unless you're inactive for four weeks. However, if I see anyone catching up, I will retaliate >:3.
Can't I be granted some sort of immunity where I don't ever get kicked off the list? :(

A few months ago you were begging Sonofkirk to get you off the list :P.

Well, I used to do that with milinko959, but not anymore, so if I do it with you, it'd be a little unfair for milinko. Why don't you make it a sort of part time - review a few submissions every few weeks to keep on the list, and maybe sometimes you can surprise us and review all of the requests? Or if you want I can reset your stats and you can start your 100% ratio afresh. I'm sure it wouldn't take too long to get to #3 again, unless Animith, RogerBK and borntodj167 get in your way, but at least we can see your awesome 100% completions again ^^. I mean, Coop83, Haggard and Fro sounds nicer than Coop83 and Haggard xP. But anyway, it's entirely your choice.

But if it wasn't for you regs, I wouldn't even be in this club anyway :/.
If it wasn't for us regs there would always be other regs probably. *Head gets bigger* But I guess it is hard to find people like us around this website. *Yawns and flexes*

Yup ^^.

Modesty shines in those words :P.
Modesty is one of my best traits, but I can go on and on about my other great traits. ;)

Lol paradox.


Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-13 12:15:21


I may not be able to finish my reviews by the end of the week, can I post my points late because I'd like to try and review everythng?


Watch how I contribute NOTHING to EVERY thread I post in!

My downloadable music | My art.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-13 12:19:22


At 3/13/10 12:15 PM, ChampionAnwar wrote: I may not be able to finish my reviews by the end of the week, can I post my points late because I'd like to try and review everythng?

You don't even need to post your points, man! That would defeat one of the main purposes of the Member's Updates. You only need to post your points for your first week, as a sort of application form to the club, but from then on, your points and stats are posted by me in the Member's Update :).


Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-13 12:38:57


I'll get this sooner or later hehehehe. Thanks for all your help man, I'll pro up in time xD.


Watch how I contribute NOTHING to EVERY thread I post in!

My downloadable music | My art.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-13 13:58:52



BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2010-03-13 15:55:10


I'll consider your reviews my birthday presents :P

Oh hey Steph.