cud i get some reviews whit this 1 plz? i wud totaly help u guys back ^_^
its a bit ambient slow at first but it kicks in at 1:52 =D
hard dance...
review plz guys rly need it :,(
Hey, thanks to you all for reviewing The Essence of Time; you were all a huge help. I managed to make a V2 based on all your criticism, so I was wondering if anyone could review it.
NOTE: This isn't a review request, so it doesn't need to be put in the list. Just asking for some reviews if you guys get the time, to see if I followed all your criticism correctly :)
Thanks :D
Man, we're packed with requests. I'll try my best to finish them all, since I don't want to make it a habit not finishing all requests, but it'll be hard, especially with my piano exam coming on Monday...
Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.
If you guys would ever so kindly review this song for me, it would be much appreciated
thanks a ton!
Howdy folks, back again for your awesome reviews. They've helped me out more than you know, and for that I am grateful. Keep up the supreme work!
Sorry If I haven't responded to all your reviews, I have been really busy. Is that ok? Do you guys get angry if I don't?
Well Anyway, here is some more stuff for you to review :D
please get me 20 votes before next teusday!
enjoy my 2nd album preview
I am open to all criticism.
This threads sounds like a great idea. I might as well throw in a couple of my pieces, see what turns up.
Art
If you could provide criticism to help me improve my art, I'd greatly appreciate it.
http://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/celes torion/celest-s-got-a-sword
Hey guys. Long time no see. Here's a new. Just in time for the new season.
When I die. It will be in a blaze of glory.
I'm going to try something new with the list. I'm only going to allow 1 audio request per person per update now as we have had too many updates with over 20 audio reviews to do and quite frankly I know some of us are tired of having to do so many. Any extra will go into the next update, but I will still list them just in case someone has enough time to work ahead.
I understand that the extra section will probably increase in the number of reviews each week, but something needed to be done to slow down the total.
So it will be a test this week and if the other members don't like the rule then we can change it back to what it use to be. So tell me what you think.
Sonofkirk will update the 2nd half of the list as usual tomorrow sometime.
Flash Requests (1)
Evil Cat By sicjes
Audio Requests (16)
Whales_{Flux} By Box-Killa
The Spinning Razor - Track 3 By JasonCD2009
(CHS) Death Match!!! By ChaosDragon004
Indication In Dictation (Demo) By ChickenGod
ISTW: Tangerine Sky By I-Saved-The-World
DJ BA - Elektronik [Sample] By DJBattleAxe
Intercontinental By curtisbalk
[NP] Alton Towers By NeonProject
-PdG- Solstice (WiP2) By Tim Blackwell (Prodigal)
PureX (Final State) By David (DavidRx)
Say Goodbye Forever By WeHaveFreshCookies
DJ Bossler - Upside Down By DJ Bossler (bossler13)
Waaaar! By Centrist
[dj-Jo] Rave Discord {AP} By Joseph (dj-Jo)
open sound By mikkim
Halloween (Brutal Mix) By Colt (Blackdoom13)
Art Requests (2)
Stoned Jesus By HighWayStar365
Celest's Got a Sword By CelestOrion
Extra Audio Requests (6)
Only 1 audio review can be requested each week per account. Any extra that are requested will be added to next week's list, but if you have time you can do them ahead of time.
Piano_Force 3 [Box-Killa] By Box-Killa
Piano_Force [Box Killa] By Box-Killa
(CHS) Do Not Resist!!! By ChaosDragon004
Gunnin' For a Knife Fight By curtisbalk
DJ BA - Front Lines By DJBattleAxe
The Spinning Razor 2 - Track By JasonCd2009
Optional Requests(1)
This is not required and will not count towards the Review Request Club.
The Essence of Time V2 By Stephan Wells (Supersteph54)
Nice new restricting rule but it gives those reviewers some actual time. Too fucking bad I have a newer version of my WIP update on a different submission. Oh well, it doesn't really matter :D
At 10/24/09 09:57 PM, Fro wrote: I'm going to try something new with the list. I'm only going to allow 1 audio request per person per update now as we have had too many updates with over 20 audio reviews to do and quite frankly I know some of us are tired of having to do so many. Any extra will go into the next update, but I will still list them just in case someone has enough time to work ahead.
Hey, that's actually a rather good idea! It gave me an idea... what if we limit to 1 request per week, but the are allowed to pst up to 3 anyway. The extra ones go in another part of the list, like you just did, and we can review them if we want - if we do, we get more points, but if we don't we won't lose our completion review. Then, to make it fair, the extra ones which have no reviews are moved on to the next extra requests in the next update, and this keeps happening till it has at least 1 review. I'd definitely work on some extra requests myself if I have time. Do you think this will work?
I understand that the extra section will probably increase in the number of reviews each week, but something needed to be done to slow down the total.
You can do my alternative :P.
Sonofkirk will update the 2nd half of the list as usual tomorrow sometime.
Anyway, thanks a lot for the update. I'm seriously thinking of making a program which does the list automatically onto a .txt file after you submit it with the required information. Would speed things up for you or whoever ends up doing the requests list next time...
Flash Requests (1)
When we get more than flash requests than audio requests, we'd know that pigs have started flying. -.-
Audio Requests (16)
Another big bunch. I regret saying that I like having more audio requests per week; they are fun to review and all, but the more I review of them, the longer my audio reviews end up being (so far I skipped the character limit 3 times T_T) and the longer it would take for me to do the audio requests...
Art Requests (2)
Not bad. A little more would be better, since I don't write such long reviews on art, and so I can finish them more quickly.
Extra Audio Requests (6)
Only 1 audio review can be requested each week per account. Any extra that are requested will be added to next week's list, but if you have time you can do them ahead of time.
So this applies for audio requests only, or does that mean flash requests and art requests get moved here too if there's more than 1 request per author?
Optional Requests(1)
The Essence of Time V2 By Stephan Wells (Supersteph54)
Thanks for putting it up there :3.
I definitely won't manage all the requests this week either. Sorry, everyone. My piano exam is tomorrow :(... Still, I finished an OK amount this week.
Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.
At 10/24/09 09:57 PM, Fro wrote: I'm going to try something new with the list. I'm only going to allow 1 audio request per person per update now as we have had too many updates with over 20 audio reviews to do and quite frankly I know some of us are tired of having to do so many. Any extra will go into the next update, but I will still list them just in case someone has enough time to work ahead.
Yeah, I totally support this - last week was absolutely manic and the amount of audio requests compared to flash and art is absolutely incredible. Perhaps this will give us a decent run at the next week now...
At 10/24/09 09:57 PM, Fro wrote: I'm going to try something new with the list. I'm only going to allow 1 audio request per person per update now as we have had too many updates with over 20 audio reviews to do and quite frankly I know some of us are tired of having to do so many. Any extra will go into the next update, but I will still list them just in case someone has enough time to work ahead.
I'm not entirely sure if I understand the extra section completly right now, but as long as you understand it everything is fine I guess. XD
Anyway, I support the idea of only 1 audio request per user per week. It's a shame that we have to do this, but it really demotivates me when I see that we have 20+ audio reviews to do. This almost makes it feel like a chore and not something I enjoy doing.
If we still have too many audio requests even with this new rule, then I might have to take more drastic actions, like not reviewing them all... *gasp*
Flash Requests (1)
Audio Requests (16)
Art Requests (2)
19 this time. Looks a lot nicer than last week. ^^
Extra Audio Requests (6)
Only 1 audio review can be requested each week per account. Any extra that are requested will be added to next week's list, but if you have time you can do them ahead of time.
We'll see how this works out. Next week we may have a lot of audio requests as well, but once the requesters internalise the new rule we may actually get fewer audio request per week. It worked really well with the "only 3 requests per week" rule, so I hope this new rule will work out just as well. :)
Surf Nazis must die! || Wi/Ht? #38
can you review this please? (it is not spam)
Bipolar Smiley: (:(
I need an honest review of this song that I made. I would really like to hear about what you really think of it. Thanks in ahead!
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/2 78644
At 10/24/09 09:57 PM, Fro wrote: The Spinning Razor - Track 3 By JasonCD2009
Due to a disagreement between myself and the artists involved here, I would move that we do not review submissions by this author or any other alternate account to do with Jason CDs or KlanMaster911.
There really isn't much quality with it and with regards to the reaction I received, I suggest that we boycott them for not being welcome here.
(Yeah I know I am probably not allowed to do this...heh ah well)
Hey there Review Request Club. Thank you to all the members that have reviewed the requests that I have made thus far I really enjoyed them. But alas I am, for the moment, unable to answer any reviews on the basis that I am having some family issues and have very little time between that and work to do much of anything (am actually typing this out quickly before I head out here). So I apologize for the long delay on responding to the reviews. I promise I will get to them when I can but for the moment they will have to simply sit there unanswered.
Thanks for your time and once again thanks for the reviews
-Tony-
I pen my life unto a paper so thin it breaks, I create my soul upon a charter so used it is lost. The pen is my weapon, my music is my heart, my soul...
At 10/26/09 09:44 AM, Cosmos8942 wrote: (Yeah I know I am probably not allowed to do this...heh ah well)
Well, it's not against the RRC or NGBBS rules, so that's good enough for me.
Thanks for letting us know - we look forward to receiving responses from you in due course.
you just say that coz your material is inferior on all levels. You cant act so you sit there and judge us like some kinda of fool.
If you were half the shit you talk about then you should trying making some decent music instead of being a douchebag.
At 10/26/09 03:40 PM, JasonCD2009 wrote:At 10/26/09 03:24 PM, KlanMaster911 wrote: you just say that coz your material is inferior on all levels. You cant act so you sit there and judge us like some kinda of fool.Exactly.
If you were half the shit you talk about then you should trying making some decent music instead of being a douchebag.
When we started writing the Jason music, we recorded so we could please others with comedy.Our comedy may be aimlessly vulgar,random and nonsensical, but still.Its just a big parody.Coop, I don't think you understand, but we are a Comedy group.We are not musicians.Whenever I record the instruments for the Jason music, I hold allot of musical ideas back.
Because its just a joke.I don't understand why you hate our ''Comedy'' so much.If you don't want to review our crappy music, then its fine.I would like to propose an idea.Whoever doesn't want to review our music and have a good laugh doesn't have to.You will not lose any points or percentages on your score.
I don't know.
Sorry to barge in, but I'd like to have my say over here:
We try and review submissions as a song themselves, not why they were written. For example, a guy requests a song that says this is his author's comments:
'My friend told me to make the most annoying song possible'
We won't judge on how annoying it is, but on how well it's written as a song, since that's supposed to be why he requested it. Our main purpose of writing reviews is to help the author improve his skills and to give honest opinions on improvements that can be made on the submission, not to praise someone for making us laugh, or saying something like 'OMG SO FUNNY!'. If you want to request a submission just to get more reviews to boast about, and not to consider our critique, then you may as well not request at all. Yes, your songs are funny, but that's the thing; their main purpose is to be funny. If you were making songs because you are aiming on getting better at making music, then it'd be a different story, but by requesting those songs of yours, it's like you're saying 'Hey guys, what do you think of this? Funny, or what?', rather than 'A review or two on this would be great because I really want to improve.'
I hope you're getting my point here...
Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.
At 10/19/09 10:14 AM, Supersteph54 wrote: Hmm... That's wierd. I'm positive I did them all...
Sorry about that I forgot requested on two songs, when I made the update. I fixed it and now, safe your states are.
At 10/24/09 09:57 PM, Fro wrote: I'm going to try something new with the list. I'm only going to allow 1 audio request per person per update now as we have had too many updates with over 20 audio reviews to do and quite frankly I know some of us are tired of having to do so many. Any extra will go into the next update, but I will still list them just in case someone has enough time to work ahead.
I like this idea, this should really decrease the overall number of audio submissions to review. Though I don't know if putting the extra ones into the next the update is a good idea since audio requests would accumulate on the list and that would make even more audio to review... I suggest to simply allow 1 audio request per person per week, let's hope people don't think it's too drastic.
Sonofkirk will update the 2nd half of the list as usual tomorrow sometime.
Thanks a bunch for doing the requests list, that's great help :).
At 10/26/09 04:22 PM, Supersteph54 wrote: We won't judge on how annoying it is, but on how well it's written as a song, since that's supposed to be why he requested it.
I couldn't agree more, if anyone isn't happy with the reviews we offer then he may not request reviews on this thread anymore.
Member's Update #17:
[#] [Total] [Total Stats] [Total Ratio] || [Gain] [Weekly Stats] [Weekly Ratio] [Username]
1 ) 2365 | 367 / 367 | 100.00% || 178 | 28 / 28 | 100.00% Coop83
2 ) 2341 | 363 / 368 | 098.64% || 178 | 28 / 28 | 100.00% Haggard
3 ) 2275 | 352 / 352 | 100.00% || 172 | 27 / 27 | 100.00% Fro
4 ) 1392 | 220 / 255 | 086.27% || 075 | 12 / 28 | 042.86% Supersteph54
5 ) 1190 | 183 / 345 | 053.04% || 000 | 00 / 28 | 000.00% Insanimation ***
06 ) 723 | 114 / 260 | 043.85% || 000 | 00 / 28 | 000.00% Soapbubble ***
07 ) 624 | 098 / 104 | 094.23% || 126 | 21 / 27 | 077.78% Darklight17
08 ) 377 | 062 / 368 | 016.85% || 000 | 00 / 28 | 000.00% milinko959 ***
09 ) 140 | 015 / 367 | 004.09% || 003 | 00 / 28 | 000.00% Sonofkirk
10 ) 090 | 014 / 105 | 013.33% || 005 | 01 / 28 | 003.57% IamWeird33
11 ) 056 | 009 / 039 | 023.08% || 012 | 02 / 28 | 007.14% CaptainAwesome121090
The stars indicate for how long the user has been inactive in this club. "Inactive" means, that user hasn't gained any points by reviewing OR by posting.
*: User has been inactive last week
**: User has been inactive for the last two weeks
***: User has been inactive for the last three weeks
****: User has been inactive for the last four weeks
If you are inactive for more than three weeks AND if your completion rate falls below 20%, OR if you are inactive for more than four weeks you are excluded from the list. You may rejoin this club, but your points will be lost.
Statistics:
*Requests this week: 28
Total requests all time: 368
Review made this week: 119
Average per member: 10.818
Average per request: 4.25
*New To the List: None
Leaving the List: None
*All Requests Completed <3:
Coop83, Haggard and Fro
Member's Update #16 - 10/18/09
FINALLY!!!
got this song done, best song ive ever made imo, let me know what you think plez :)
At 10/26/09 05:02 PM, Sonofkirk wrote: Member's Update #17:
Thanks for the update!
[#] [Total] [Total Stats] [Total Ratio] || [Gain] [Weekly Stats] [Weekly Ratio] [Username]
1 ) 2365 | 367 / 367 | 100.00% || 178 | 28 / 28 | 100.00% Coop83
2 ) 2341 | 363 / 368 | 098.64% || 178 | 28 / 28 | 100.00% Haggard
3 ) 2275 | 352 / 352 | 100.00% || 172 | 27 / 27 | 100.00% Fro
Three amigos strike again. Surprisingly enough it wasn't so hard to get all the requests done. Maybe because I had to hurry a bit as I had very little time to do reviews this weekend, so I wrote a lot of the reviews on Monday so I had less left for the rest of the week.
5 ) 1190 | 183 / 345 | 053.04% || 000 | 00 / 28 | 000.00% Insanimation ***
06 ) 723 | 114 / 260 | 043.85% || 000 | 00 / 28 | 000.00% Soapbubble ***
Wake up!
*All Requests Completed <3:
Coop83, Haggard and Fro
Only 3 this time? :(
Surf Nazis must die! || Wi/Ht? #38
Hey guys, I would much appreciate your thoughts on my new songs I am currently trying to get better at making songs just no feedback to help me :/
Thanks again, Liam3003.
At 10/26/09 05:02 PM, Sonofkirk wrote:At 10/19/09 10:14 AM, Supersteph54 wrote: Hmm... That's wierd. I'm positive I did them all...Sorry about that I forgot requested on two songs, when I made the update. I fixed it and now, safe your states are.
Apology accepted :). Not such a big deal, anyway ;).
Member's Update #17:
[#] [Total] [Total Stats] [Total Ratio] || [Gain] [Weekly Stats] [Weekly Ratio] [Username]
1 ) 2365 | 367 / 367 | 100.00% || 178 | 28 / 28 | 100.00% Coop83
2 ) 2341 | 363 / 368 | 098.64% || 178 | 28 / 28 | 100.00% Haggard
3 ) 2275 | 352 / 352 | 100.00% || 172 | 27 / 27 | 100.00% Fro
Wow, good job on doing all the requests; TBH I thought at least one of you guys wasn't going to make it :P.
4 ) 1392 | 220 / 255 | 086.27% || 075 | 12 / 28 | 042.86% Supersteph54
Gah, my stats have become horrible now :(. Well, finished my piano exam, so I should be able to finish all the requests this week.
5 ) 1190 | 183 / 345 | 053.04% || 000 | 00 / 28 | 000.00% Insanimation ***
06 ) 723 | 114 / 260 | 043.85% || 000 | 00 / 28 | 000.00% Soapbubble ***
I agree with Haggard, wake up! If you don't Darklight will be only one place behind me! :(
07 ) 624 | 098 / 104 | 094.23% || 126 | 21 / 27 | 077.78% Darklight17
Hehe, no more 100%, eh Darklight?
*All Requests Completed <3:
Coop83, Haggard and Fro
Next week...
Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.
I'm making a rare return to the Forums to ask you guys for a review on my cartoon, since 95% of the ones I've gotten haven't been helpful at all.
Thanks.
At 10/26/09 03:24 PM, KlanMaster911 wrote: you just say that coz your material is inferior on all levels. You cant act so you sit there and judge us like some kinda of fool.
Well, I'm not trying to compare myself to you, so your opinion is okay by me. You're in the minority of people who think that I'm a shit reviewer and if you've got some grievance about reviews, please feel free to contact me via PM, as I'm a review mod.
If you were half the shit you talk about then you should trying making some decent music instead of being a douchebag.
I don't try to make some 'decent music', because I don't have the ability or the inclination to do so.
At 10/26/09 03:40 PM, JasonCD2009 wrote: Because its just a joke.I don't understand why you hate our ''Comedy'' so much.If you don't want to review our crappy music, then its fine.I would like to propose an idea.Whoever doesn't want to review our music and have a good laugh doesn't have to.You will not lose any points or percentages on your score.
No, that's not how the club works. I know you're only trying to help, but the point is that I'm trying to be objective about your submissions. This leads me to say that your guitar is good to great, but you really need to do something about the vocals, as they really drag the quality of the piece down.
As for comedy, it's not working for me - comedy is something that makes me laugh, where these pieces I find marginally less amusing than "The Office"
At 10/26/09 05:02 PM, Sonofkirk wrote: 1 ) 2365 | 367 / 367 | 100.00% || 178 | 28 / 28 | 100.00% Coop83
2 ) 2341 | 363 / 368 | 098.64% || 178 | 28 / 28 | 100.00% Haggard
3 ) 2275 | 352 / 352 | 100.00% || 172 | 27 / 27 | 100.00% Fro
Thanks for the update, Sonofkirk. Nice work
Holiday starts tomorrow and I should be able to get the RRC done in 1 day this time.
*All Requests Completed <3:
Coop83, Haggard and Fro
Wow, and I thought 4 was a bad week last week :(
At 10/26/09 05:08 PM, JasonCD2009 wrote: I understand you all the way SuperSteph54.What my friend KlanMaster911 is trying to say, is that he feels that Coops reviews are biased and overly critical.In the long run, I don't fully agree with his methods of dealing with Coop, but whatever.You listen to our shitty music and write reviews for free.I understand this, and you are entitled to your opinions.
As I've said before, he is entitled to his opinion about that. There are issues between the two of us and a big difference of opinion in that I believe I can write and voice funnier stuff than I've heard from KlanMaster. Just because he has a different opinion to me does not mean that either of our opinions are wrong, we must just agree to disagree.
If you have heard our older music, it is true that you have helped us improve over the years.Just keep in mind that me and KlanMaster911 are two completely different people on two completely different accounts.I write the Guitar riffs,the bass lines and program the drums.I speak for my self, and my self only.
Perhaps you should submit some of your own solo guitar work, to show how good you have become?
