00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

MauveDash just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Review Ban Woes Are History!

6,913 Views | 90 Replies

Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:17:44


It's been a long time coming, but we have found some time and resources to work on the review mod tools! Now that we have both Ross and Liljim doing all our back end programming, they each have more time to work on more things. While they have both been very busy with the redesign, Ross was able to spend some time improving the review mod tools. Review mods can now set bans like they do on the forums, that expire automatically. This means a review mod can ban a user who submits a rule breaking review from 2-30 days. Most bans will probably be short if it's a basic offenses, but repeat offenders beware!

In addition, a copy of your rule breaking review and a ban reason from the mod will be automatically sent to your PM inbox! We are trying hard to make the site more fair, and fun, for everyone involved. We hope this improvement in communication makes things easier on those getting banned. In the past they would typically email me, or others, asking why they were banned. Now they will know why they were banned and won't have to inquire about their ban.

There may be a lot more bans being handed out howerver. The mods would often hold back on banning users for small offenses because they knew they maybe sentancing them to a 2-3 month ban, or longer. Now they can give a 2-3 day ban if they feel it's a small offense, but it lets the user know they did something wrong and they can hopefully learn from the mistake.

Also review mods can now delete reviews that are within a certain time frame (they can't delete older reviews) and they can delete reviews that are flagged as abusive, or clear flags from reviews that aren't abusive.

All of this will hopefully greatly clean up the Newgrounds review system. It may take a few weeks for them to catch up on some of the backed up crap, but eventually we will hopefully get on top of all the bad reviews. More review mods will probably be added. (Don't ask to be one as they are nominated).

So if you're not a review mod, how can you help? Flag those abusive reviews! We have increased the power of user whistles! The system we had gave the top power to the user with the most whistle points, and users with less whistle points had less power, but as the top user moved higher up, the majority of the users far behind got less and less power. We have changed that to a fixed scale so now all users wiith positive whistle points will have more power than they did before.

On the other hand we increased the penalty for users who use the abusive flag to flag legit reviews that aren't abusive. Don't worry to much, everyone has been doing a great job. If you think a review is abusive and understand our review rules, it's probably an abusive review. We're talking about users who know a review isn't abusive, but flag it anyway. When the review mods see these legit reviews showing up in their list they will clear these bogus flags, and the users behind them will get negative whistle points. If a user gets to many negative points their whistle becomes useless until they build their points back up by flagging truely abusive reviews.

So get out there and flag those abusive reviews! We really want to put the lid on users who leave reviews insulting the author. So if you see a reviewer insulting the author, rather than the Flash, flag the review as abusive!


Follow me on Twitter! TWITTER

Be my Facebook friend! FACEBOOK

Google+ Profile

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:19:11


Go freedom!


He'd Look Just Like You'd Want Him Too, Some Kind of Slick Chrome American Prince.

Tweet//LastFM//Qwantz//Blog

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:20:18


Excellent, nice to see more progress here.


I hardly ever come here anymore....

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:20:52


That's cool. Being in the thread i think the whistle level busting on the reviews is broken or at least it should be easier to understand.

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:23:37


Nice job, guys.

Another thing i wanted to ask you about (I didn't see it anywhere on your site) who do i PM if i find a bug in the site? I think it would seem obvious to PM you or Tom but if there was someone who would get it faster or something, it might be better to PM him.

Or don't you care about these kinds of PMs? It would be nice to know as i found a few bugs on the site.


EVERYBODY! I beg of you, if you have a Facebook profile CLICK this LINK and press the red button that says 'stem'. Help me create television HISTORY, it takes 30 seconds!

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:23:58


You should make it so if we click our profile only we can see our progress till the next whistle.

I think that would be a splended idea.

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:24:53


This is awesome! But if you get review banned, your quite pathetic.


Skype: the_sleuth

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:25:14


I have to say, that's a massive improvement on the old system.


Formerly TheMaster | PSN: Absurd-Ditties | Steam | Letterboxd

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:25:38


Excellent! Although I've never been review banned, but this is great since now whoever gets banned won't be banned for a long time and won't know when exactly their ban will end. Heh, the other day, I was wondering if the improvement on the review banning system would be done and here it is.

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:26:54


Progress is a wonderful thing.

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:27:11


At 10/6/06 11:19 AM, WilliWowza wrote: Go freedom!

agreeeeeeeeeeed


What would you do?

"Two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity." - Albert Einstein

Yes, Newgrounds, that quote is dedicated 4 you.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:28:44


I've never been review banned before, so that didn't really make much difference to me, but I suppose it will be good for me in the future, as I will be active in the Portal more often now, and might slip up here and there.

Good job.

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:29:09


It's certainly a good change, but why did it take you so long to implement it?

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:30:17


yay new mod tools!


I'd put something witty here, but that would be pointless and unoriginal.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:35:35


Well that's cool to know. Reviews are a bit of a joke for most submissions anyway. Now to sort out getting submission banned, that is the most annoying thing ever.


WEBSITE

BLOG ~ Dont fuck around with my dog. All that I can see I steal. ~

NG FFR ~ Automatic for the people.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:42:44


Can I slag off IWP yet?


"Some kilometers SOUTH of Dublin, under more control of

the IRA, there is a vast farmland. I'm SUPER cereal"

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:43:27


It's about time, this is one of the best things to happen to NG for a while.


BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:43:46


At 10/6/06 11:23 AM, PT wrote: Nice job, guys.

Another thing i wanted to ask you about (I didn't see it anywhere on your site) who do i PM if i find a bug in the site?

If you think you've found a genuine bug, PM LilJim or Ross.


Follow me on Twitter! TWITTER

Be my Facebook friend! FACEBOOK

Google+ Profile

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:44:58


Review bans...

Now the only problem is getting submission bans PROPERLY checked on.

I've submitted a couple and the movie never gets blammed.

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:55:56


At 10/6/06 11:44 AM, TurtleLove117 wrote: Now the only problem is getting submission bans PROPERLY checked on.

If you're talking about portal entries that are flagged for admin review, that's something we want to tackle soon.


Follow me on Twitter! TWITTER

Be my Facebook friend! FACEBOOK

Google+ Profile

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 11:57:52


So everyone who has a review ban now gets lifted???

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 12:00:00


At 10/6/06 11:55 AM, WadeFulp wrote:
At 10/6/06 11:44 AM, TurtleLove117 wrote: Now the only problem is getting submission bans PROPERLY checked on.
If you're talking about portal entries that are flagged for admin review, that's something we want to tackle soon.

Yes exactly, alot of flashes either aren't BLAMMED, or are BLAMMED hours after they're flagged.

Example.

Dark Victory

That one made it past the Portal, flagged it, but it's still there.

It's good to see you're going to handle it soon though.

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 12:00:17


Is it possible to have it that artists responses could be marked as abusive too?

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 12:06:41


Definitely a huge improvement on the old review ban system, good work guys.


i think newgrounds is a pretty cool guy. eh makes falsh and doesn't afraid of anything.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 12:18:56


Watch out people!!!!!

I have been holding back on a lot of small offense.

I will be enfore the rules

Make sure to read them!

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 12:22:10


Abusive reviews are highlarious


"What is a joke exactly?"

BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 12:22:57


Congradulations you threw your dick into yet another part of the site.


BBS Signature

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 12:23:43


nice wade, atleast people might be a bit more careful when writing reviews


Awesome post great job!

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 12:29:33


Good news, it's always nice to see the site's system getting improved.

Response to Review Ban Woes Are History! 2006-10-06 12:32:41


Yea, as ramagi and Wade have said, we aren't being as lenient on the review guidelines, now that we're not committing to banning people for months on end.

If you're saying stuff like "I did not like this movie" you might get banned for a couple days. Why? Because reviews are a space to not only give your personal opinion, but also to explain WHY so that the author can improve their submissions in the future. "I did not like this movie" is not helpful in the slightest. You might not get banned, but it probably isn't worth the risk.


BBS Signature